Causes and consequences of variation in female mate search investment in a lekking bird

Why do females faced with the same array of potential mates often select different males? Variation in choosiness, defined as investment in mate search, is an important potential source of variation in mating decisions. Experimental work suggests such variation is driven by the costs of searching, but data from natural populations are scarce and few studies have addressed explicitly the counteracting benefits expected from search investment. We tracked male visitation behavior of free-ranging females on a lek of lance-tailed manakins (Chiroxiphia lanceolata) using automated telemetry at dispersed male display sites. We assessed relationships of female age, experience, body condition, and parasite load with variation in choosiness, quantified as males visited, number of visits, and visit duration. Young females visited more males and made more total visits before choosing a mate, whereas older females conducted longer visits for first nests of the year. Renesting females searched less, but the few monitored females mating faithfully between years nevertheless sampled several males. We found little support for effects of condition on choosiness. Results suggest females sample more widely when they lack information about the distribution of available mates. Though previous work in the study population has shown both female preference for and offspring fitness benefits from heterozygous sires, genetic tests of paternity revealed choosier females did not choose more heterozygous mates. Females’ investment in mate search varied in relation to their own age and within-year experience, but mate search investment did not independently determine variation in choice among individuals.