Forecast combinations for value at risk and expected shortfall

Combining provides a pragmatic way of synthesising the information provided by individual forecasting methods. In the context of forecasting the mean, numerous studies have shown that combining often leads to improvements in accuracy. Despite the importance of the value at risk (VaR), though, few papers have considered quantile forecast combinations. One risk measure that is receiving an increasing amount of attention is the expected shortfall (ES), which is the expectation of the exceedances beyond the VaR. There have been no previous studies on combining ES predictions, presumably due to there being no suitable loss function for ES. However, it has been shown recently that a set of scoring functions exist for the joint estimation or backtesting of VaR and ES forecasts. We use such scoring functions to estimate combining weights for VaR and ES prediction. The results from five stock indices show that combining outperforms the individual methods for the 1% and 5% probability levels.