The Structure of Academic Achievement: Searching for Proximal Mechanisms Using Causal Discovery Algorithms

Causal search algorithms have been effectively applied in different fields including biology, genetics, climate science, medicine, and neuroscience. However, there have been scant applications of these methods in social and behavioral sciences. This article provides an illustrative example of how causal search algorithms can shed light on important social and behavioral problems by using these algorithms to find the proximal mechanisms of academic achievement. Using a nationally representative data set with a wide range of relevant contextual and psychological factors, I implement four causal search procedures that varied important dimensions in the algorithms. Consistent with previous research, the algorithms identified prior achievement, executive functions (in particular, working memory, cognitive flexibility, and attentional focusing), and motivation as direct causes of academic achievement. I discuss the advantages and limitations of graphical models in general and causal search algorithms in particular for understanding social and behavioral problems.