Closed-Boundary Reflections of Shallow Water Waves as an Open Challenge for Physics-Informed Neural Networks

Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) have recently emerged as a promising alternative to traditional numerical methods for solving partial differential equations (PDEs) in fluid dynamics. By using PDE-derived loss functions and auto-differentiation, PINNs can recover solutions without requiring costly simulation data, spatial gridding, or time discretization. However, PINNs often exhibit slow or incomplete convergence, depending on the architecture, optimization algorithms, and complexity of the PDEs. To address these difficulties, a variety of novel and repurposed techniques have been introduced to improve convergence. Despite these efforts, their effectiveness is difficult to assess due to the wide range of problems and network architectures. As a novel test case for PINNs, we propose one-dimensional shallow water equations with closed boundaries, where the solutions exhibit repeated boundary wave reflections. After carefully constructing a reference solution, we evaluate the performance of PINNs across different architectures, optimizers, and special training techniques. Despite the simplicity of the problem for classical methods, PINNs only achieve accurate results after prohibitively long training times. While some techniques provide modest improvements in stability and accuracy, this problem remains an open challenge for PINNs, suggesting that it could serve as a valuable testbed for future research on PINN training techniques and optimization strategies.